Search for your main service plus "Red Deer" and you may find businesses ahead of you that you would expect to be behind: newer firms, smaller ones, or companies based elsewhere along the Highway 2 corridor. That is usually not luck. Google explains in general terms how it ranks local results, and once you understand it you can work out where you are falling short.

Two kinds of results

A local search usually shows two different sets of results:

  • The map pack: the map and the short list of businesses under it, drawn from Google Business Profiles.
  • Organic results: the regular website listings below.

They are ranked differently. The map pack depends heavily on your Business Profile; organic rankings depend heavily on your website. You can do well in one and poorly in the other, so check both.

There may also be ads at the top, such as Google Ads and, for some service categories, Local Services Ads. Those are paid placements and separate from the rankings discussed here.

What Google says it looks at

Google's help pages say local results are based mainly on three things:

  • Relevance: how well a profile matches what someone searched for. Your categories, services, description and website content all feed into this.
  • Distance: how far the business is from the location in the search, or from the searcher if no location is given. Someone in Johnstone Park and someone in Anders may see different results for the same search.
  • Prominence: how well known the business is. Google refers to information from across the web, such as links, articles and directories, and says review count and rating play a part. Your position in organic results also counts.

You can't change your location, but relevance and prominence are largely in your control. That is why a business further away can outrank a closer one: if it is clearly more relevant and more prominent, distance alone may not make up the difference.

A diagnosis you can do in an hour

Pick your three most important searches, for example "furnace repair Red Deer", "plumber Sylvan Lake" or "roofing Lacombe", and work through these steps:

  1. Search like a customer. Use your phone in a private window. Note who appears in the map pack and the top organic results. If you can, search from different parts of town and from nearby towns, since results change with location.
  2. Compare primary categories. In Google Maps, the category shown under a business name is usually its primary category. If the businesses above you use a more specific category than you do, that is often the first fix.
  3. Compare reviews. Note the count, the rating, how recent the latest reviews are, and whether the owner replies.
  4. Compare websites. Does the competitor have a dedicated page for the exact service searched? Do you? A single "Services" page that lists everything is often outranked by a page about one service.
  5. Check your profile basics. Name, address or service area, phone, hours, website link, services and photos. Is anything missing, wrong or out of date?
  6. Check that Google can see your site. In Google Search Console, confirm your important pages are indexed and see which searches you already appear for.

Write down where you are behind. That is your to-do list.

What to fix, in order

1. Your Google Business Profile

  • Choose the most specific primary category for your main business, and add secondary categories only for things you really do.
  • Use your real business name. Adding keywords or town names to it is against Google's guidelines and can get a profile suspended.
  • If you serve customers at their homes or sites and don't receive them at your premises, set up as a service-area business: hide your address and list the towns you serve. Google's guidelines say a service area shouldn't extend beyond roughly two hours' drive from where the business is based.
  • List your services and write a plain description of what you do and where.
  • Add real photos of your work, vehicles and team, and keep adding them.
  • Keep hours accurate, including holidays.

2. Service pages on your website

Create a page for each main service: what it is, who it is for, the areas you cover, what the process looks like and how to get a quote. Link to the relevant page from your Business Profile.

Add pages for nearby towns only when you can say something specific about working there, such as the jobs you've done or how you schedule visits. Pages with nothing but the town name changed add little and can be treated as doorway pages.

3. Reviews

Ask every satisfied customer for a review soon after the job, with a direct link. Reply to every review, including negative ones, calmly and specifically. Don't offer discounts or gifts in exchange for reviews, don't ask only the customers you expect to be happy, and never post reviews yourself. All of these go against Google's policies.

4. Citations and links

Make sure your business name, address and phone number are consistent on the listings that matter: Bing Places, Apple Business Connect, Yelp, HomeStars, your trade association, and the Red Deer Chamber of Commerce directory if you are a member. Genuine local links, such as a sponsorship page, a supplier's dealer list or a news story about your business, help build prominence. Avoid paid link schemes.

5. Ongoing activity

Keep the profile current: new photos, replies to reviews, and updates when services or hours change. Business Profile posts are optional, but they are an easy way to show recent work.

What not to do

  • Don't set up a virtual office or borrowed address in another town to appear there. It is against Google's guidelines and such profiles can be removed.
  • Don't create more than one profile for the same business.
  • Don't buy reviews or links.

Measure what changes

Use the Performance section of your Google Business Profile to track calls, website clicks and direction requests, and Search Console to track searches and clicks to your site. Repeat the one-hour diagnosis every couple of months. Rankings move slowly and vary by location, so look at trends over months rather than daily positions.

Want a second opinion?

Velora works with Red Deer and Central Alberta businesses remotely. If you'd like us to run this diagnosis for your main services and tell you what we would fix first, get in touch.