If you run a trades business in Red Deer (HVAC, plumbing, electrical, roofing, landscaping, renovation) you have probably been told you need to "get on Google." There are several different ways to do that, they work very differently, and they suit different situations. This article explains each one, shows you how to judge them with your own numbers, and lays out a sensible way to combine them.
The three ways to appear on Google
Google Ads (search ads). You choose keywords such as "plumber Red Deer" or "furnace repair near me", set a budget, and your ad can appear at the top of the results with a "Sponsored" label. You pay when someone clicks, whether or not they hire you. Ads can start running quickly, and they stop the moment you stop paying.
Local Services Ads (LSAs). These appear above regular search ads for eligible trades, show a Google verification badge, and charge per lead (a call or message) rather than per click. Your business goes through Google's screening first, which can include background and licence checks. Not every trade is eligible in every area, so check Google's Local Services site for your category in Red Deer.
SEO (organic and map results). You improve your website, Google Business Profile and wider online presence so that Google chooses to show you in the unpaid results and the map pack. It takes longer to build, nobody can guarantee a position, and it needs ongoing work, but you do not pay for each click.
The real question is not which is better in general. It is which makes sense for your business, your margins and your cash flow right now.
Work out your own numbers first
Before comparing options, work out what a lead is worth to you. You need three figures from your own records:
- Average job value for the service you want more of (for example furnace replacement versus a service call).
- Close rate: of the people who contact you, how many become paying jobs?
- Gross margin on that job.
Then, for Google Ads, the basic arithmetic is:
- Cost per lead = cost per click ÷ the share of clicks that become calls or form submissions.
- Cost per job = cost per lead ÷ your close rate.
Google's Keyword Planner gives estimated cost-per-click ranges for your keywords and area. Your own campaign data replaces those estimates within a few weeks. Compare your cost per job with your margin on that job. High-value jobs (replacements, installs, roofs) can usually carry a higher cost per job than small repairs. Do this calculation per service, not for the business as a whole.
For SEO, the calculation is different: you are paying for work over months, and the return depends on which searches you eventually rank for. Track it by the number of calls and form submissions coming from organic and map results, and divide what you spent by the jobs they produced.
When Google Ads makes sense
- You need leads soon (new business, slow season, new service area).
- The job value is high enough that paying per click still leaves a healthy margin.
- You want to test which services and towns produce the best leads before investing in SEO pages for them.
- You want to cover emergency searches ("no heat", "burst pipe") where being at the top right now matters.
Ways to waste money on Ads:
- Broad keywords with no negative keywords, so you pay for searches like "plumber jobs" or "how to fix a furnace yourself."
- Targeting all of Central Alberta when you only want work in Red Deer, Sylvan Lake, Blackfalds or Lacombe. Use location targeting set to people in your area.
- Sending clicks to your homepage instead of a page for that service.
- Running ads 24/7 when nobody answers the phone after hours. Use an ad schedule, or run call-only ads only when someone can pick up.
- Not tracking calls. Set up call tracking and conversion tracking so you know which keywords produce jobs, not just clicks.
When SEO makes sense
- You plan to be in business in Red Deer for years and want a source of leads that does not stop when the budget does.
- You are willing to wait several months for results, and to keep at it.
- Your reviews and reputation are good, or you are ready to build them.
What SEO work for a contractor actually involves:
- Google Business Profile: correct primary category, services listed, service area set to the towns you really serve, photos of real jobs, and regular updates.
- Reviews: ask every customer, make it easy with your review link, and reply to every review. Never offer discounts or gifts for reviews, which breaks Google's policies.
- Service pages: one page per main service (furnace repair, AC installation, drain cleaning) with real detail: what you do, what it involves, what affects the price, and how to book.
- Service-area pages, done carefully: only for towns where you actually work, each with genuinely useful local information. Copy-paste pages with the town name swapped are thin content that Google tends to ignore.
- Technical basics: a fast, mobile-friendly site, LocalBusiness structured data, and Google Search Console set up so you can see which searches you appear for.
- Consistent listings: the same name, address and phone number on directories, the Red Deer & District Chamber of Commerce if you are a member, trade associations and suppliers' "find a contractor" pages.
A phased plan that uses both
For many Red Deer contractors the sensible answer is both, with the balance changing over time.
Phase 1 (roughly the first three months): ads for cash flow, SEO foundations underneath. Run tightly targeted search ads (and LSAs if eligible) for your most profitable services. At the same time, fix your Google Business Profile, start asking for reviews, and build or rewrite your main service pages.
Phase 2 (roughly months three to six): watch where leads come from. Check Search Console and your call tracking. Where you start appearing organically for a keyword, test reducing ad spend on it and watch whether total leads hold. Keep ads running for terms where you do not yet appear.
Phase 3 (after six months or so): ads as a targeted tool. If organic and map results are producing steady leads, keep ads for emergency keywords, seasonal pushes (furnaces in the fall, AC in early summer), new services or new towns.
The timings are a guide, not a promise. How fast SEO results arrive depends on your starting point, your category and what other businesses in your area are doing. Let your own data, not the calendar, decide when to shift budget.
Two common mistakes
Ads forever, with nothing else. If you only ever buy clicks, your cost of getting leads never falls on its own, and when you stop paying the leads stop. Even a modest, steady investment in your Google Business Profile, reviews and service pages builds something that keeps working.
SEO alone when you need work this month. SEO is not a switch. If you need jobs to make payroll in the next few weeks, start with ads (or LSAs) and build SEO alongside them.
The bottom line
Google Ads and LSAs buy visibility now. SEO builds visibility that lasts but takes time. Work out your cost per job for each service, start with what your cash flow needs, and move budget towards organic as your own tracking shows it is producing.
If you would like help running these numbers for your trade and setting up the tracking to make the decision with real data, get in touch. We work with Red Deer contractors remotely, and you can see our pricing page for what our services cost.