If you run a plumbing, HVAC, electrical, roofing or renovation business in Red Deer, you have probably been pitched a HomeStars upgrade, a Yelp advertising package and an SEO service, sometimes in the same week. Each can bring in work. They differ in who owns the customer relationship, how their costs behave over time, and how quickly they produce leads. This article sets out how to compare them using your own numbers.
How HomeStars works
HomeStars is a Canadian home-improvement platform where homeowners look for contractors, read reviews and post projects. Contractors can list a business profile, and paid plans add visibility and access to project requests. Plans, prices and the way leads are distributed change over time and can vary by trade and area, so get the current terms in writing before you sign up, including:
- How you are charged: a monthly membership, per lead, or both.
- Whether leads are exclusive to you or sent to several contractors.
- Contract length and cancellation terms.
- Whether you can dispute leads that turn out to be invalid.
If a lead goes to several contractors, you are paying for a chance to compete, not for a job. That can still be worthwhile, as long as you know it and price it in.
How Yelp works
Yelp gives businesses a free page where customers can leave reviews. Paid options include advertising that shows your business more prominently in Yelp search results and on other businesses' pages, usually charged per click, plus profile upgrades. One rule matters a lot: Yelp's guidelines tell businesses not to ask customers for Yelp reviews. That limits how actively you can build your Yelp profile compared with your Google profile.
How much homeowners in your trade use Yelp, HomeStars or Google varies. Before spending more on any of them, check your own records for where your calls actually come from.
How SEO and your Google Business Profile work
For a trades business, SEO means making your Google Business Profile and website the best match for searches like "furnace repair Red Deer" or "electrician Sylvan Lake", so you appear in the map results and the regular listings. It includes:
- A complete Google Business Profile with the right categories, the service areas you genuinely cover (Red Deer, Blackfalds, Lacombe, Sylvan Lake, Penhold, Innisfail and so on), accurate hours and real photos.
- A website with a page for each core service, honest guidance on pricing where you can give it, and a phone number that is easy to find on a phone.
- A steady flow of Google reviews. Google allows you to ask customers for reviews, but not to offer anything in return or to ask only the customers you expect to be happy.
- Consistent business details on relevant directories, including your HomeStars and Yelp pages.
- Helpful content that answers the questions customers ask before they hire.
A lead from organic search or your profile isn't handed to other contractors by a platform: the homeowner picks you from the results. You are still compared with competitors, but on your reviews, photos and website rather than in a shared lead pool.
Work out what a job actually costs you
Pull three numbers from your own records for each channel over the same period:
- Total spend: membership, lead fees, ad spend, or SEO costs (including your own time).
- Leads: calls, form submissions or project requests.
- Jobs won.
Then calculate:
- Cost per lead = spend ÷ leads.
- Close rate = jobs won ÷ leads.
- Cost per job won = spend ÷ jobs won.
For example, if you close one lead in five, each job won costs you five times the price of a lead, before materials and labour. Compare that with your average gross margin per job. Do the same for every channel, including SEO once it has had time to produce results.
Two more things to note for each channel:
- Job size. One channel may bring more small repair calls and another more larger projects.
- Repeat and referral value. A customer who contacted you directly is easier to stay in touch with, for example for annual maintenance reminders.
Who owns the relationship
The main structural difference is ownership. On a platform, your profile, your reviews and often the first contact with the customer sit on someone else's property, and the platform sets the prices and the rules. If it raises fees, changes how leads are shared or changes how it ranks contractors, you adapt or leave, and the reviews you built stay behind.
Google isn't static either: it changes its results regularly. But your website, your phone number, your customer list and the content you have written belong to you, and reviews on your Google Business Profile stay attached to your business.
When the platforms make sense
- You are new and have no website, reviews or rankings yet. A platform can bring in jobs while you build your own presence.
- You have gaps in the schedule that you need to fill quickly.
- The numbers work. If your cost per job won through a platform sits comfortably below your margin and the work suits you, there is no reason to stop.
- Your customers use it. If customers in your trade regularly tell you they found you there, keep a strong profile.
The risk is staying dependent by default: joining as a stopgap and never building anything of your own.
A phased approach
- Claim and complete your free profiles on Google, HomeStars and Yelp, with the same name, address and phone number on each.
- Use paid platforms deliberately. Set a monthly cap and a date to review the results.
- Build your own channel in parallel: service pages, pages for the Central Alberta communities you actually serve, a routine for asking for Google reviews after every job, and tracking.
- Track sources. Use a separate tracking phone number for each channel where you can, tag your web forms, and ask every new customer how they found you.
- Review quarterly and move budget toward whatever produces jobs at the best cost per job won.
Common mistakes
- Comparing cost per lead instead of cost per job won.
- Not tracking where calls come from.
- Asking customers for Yelp reviews, which goes against Yelp's guidelines.
- Offering discounts or gifts in exchange for Google reviews, which goes against Google's policies.
- Letting your Google Business Profile go stale while paying for platform leads.
Next step
If you'd like to see how your trades business currently shows up on Google in Red Deer and across Central Alberta, request a free audit. We'll show you where you appear today and what we would work on first. For what our services cost, see our pricing page.