When a website is built on Next.js, the content usually lives somewhere else: in a headless content management system, or CMS. Your team edits text, images and pages there, and the website pulls that content in. Choosing the right CMS matters more than most business owners expect, because it is the part of the website your team will actually use every week.

This guide compares three popular options, Sanity, Contentful and Payload, along with two simpler alternatives, and explains which kind of business each tends to suit. It deliberately leaves out prices, because vendor plans change often. Check each provider's current plans before you decide.

What "headless" means here

A traditional CMS such as WordPress stores your content and also builds the pages visitors see. A headless CMS only stores and manages content. The website, in our case built with Next.js, asks the CMS for content through an API and decides how to display it.

The benefits are flexibility and speed: the same content can feed a website, an app or several sites, and the front end can be built for performance without the CMS getting in the way. The trade-off is that someone has to set up the connection between the two, and the editing experience depends heavily on which CMS you pick and how it is configured.

Questions to answer before choosing

  • Who will edit the content, and how often? One person updating a page a month has very different needs from a marketing team publishing daily.
  • How structured is your content? Services, locations, team members, products and case studies benefit from structured content types rather than free-form pages.
  • Do you need more than one language? Built-in localization features vary.
  • Do editors need to preview changes before publishing?
  • Where should the data live? On the vendor's platform, or in a database you control?
  • What happens if you change providers later? How easy is it to export your content?

Sanity

Sanity combines a hosted content platform with an editing interface called Sanity Studio, which is configured in code and can be customized extensively.

  • Strengths: very flexible content modelling, real-time collaborative editing, and an editing interface that can be tailored closely to how your team works. Content is queried through Sanity's own query language, GROQ, or GraphQL.
  • Considerations: because so much is defined in code, a developer sets up the content structure and changes to it. The content itself is stored on Sanity's hosted platform.
  • Tends to suit: businesses with varied or highly structured content and editors who will use the CMS often, where a tailored editing experience is worth the setup.

Contentful

Contentful is a long-established, fully hosted content platform used widely by larger organizations.

  • Strengths: a mature, polished web interface for editors, content models that can be managed through that interface, REST and GraphQL APIs, and well-developed features for roles, permissions, workflows and localization.
  • Considerations: it is a hosted service, so your content lives on Contentful's platform, and plan limits such as the number of users, content types or locales are worth checking carefully against your needs as you grow.
  • Tends to suit: organizations with several editors, approval workflows or multiple languages, who want a stable hosted platform with established governance features.

Payload

Payload is an open-source CMS written in TypeScript. In recent versions it can run inside the same Next.js application as the website itself.

  • Strengths: you host it and keep the data in your own database, which gives you control and avoids per-seat platform limits. The admin panel is generated from the content configuration, and because it is open source there is no platform lock-in.
  • Considerations: you are responsible for hosting, the database, backups and updates, as with any self-hosted software. Content structure changes are made in code by a developer.
  • Tends to suit: businesses that want their content and data under their own control, or projects where the website and CMS benefit from living in one codebase.

Two simpler alternatives

  • WordPress as a headless CMS. Your team keeps the familiar WordPress dashboard, and Next.js pulls the content through its API. A good fit when editors already know WordPress well. You still need to keep WordPress itself updated and secure.
  • File-based content. For small sites that rarely change, content can live in files alongside the code, with no separate CMS at all. It is simple, fast and has nothing extra to pay for, but edits usually go through a developer.

A quick way to narrow it down

  • A small site that changes a few times a year: file-based content is often enough.
  • Editors who already know WordPress: consider headless WordPress.
  • A team publishing often, with structured content and a tailored workflow: Sanity is a strong candidate.
  • Several editors, approvals and multiple languages on a hosted platform: Contentful is a strong candidate.
  • You want the data in your own database and no platform dependency: Payload is a strong candidate.

These are starting points, not rules. Each of these platforms can handle more than the box we put it in here.

What matters more than the brand

Whichever CMS you choose, the setup makes the biggest difference to your team's experience: clear content types with sensible names, fields that match how you think about your business, help text where editors need it, a preview of changes before publishing, and roles so people only see what they need. A well-configured simple CMS beats a powerful one set up carelessly.

Also make sure the CMS account is in your name and that you can export your content, so the choice never locks you in.

How we approach it

We pick the CMS with you, based on who will edit the site, how often and how your content is structured, and for very small sites we will tell you when you do not need one at all. If you are planning a Next.js build or moving off WordPress and want help choosing, get in touch.